plan: carry W0's verdict into the wave table (W2 blocked-by-OGAR-mint-decision, W1 proceeds)

.claude/plans/r2il-machine-semantic-contract-v1.md

@@ -208,8 +208,8 @@ per workspace rule (grindwork → Sonnet; accumulation/orchestration/gates
 | wave | deliverable | falsifier / kill condition |
 |---|---|---|
 | **W0** | ~~`Custom(n)` census~~ **RUN 2026-08-25 — see the ⊘ note in §3.** Census: 0 custom spaces in 94,536 rows / 4 binaries (latent). Mechanism falsified in code: the lo-u16 is a rank in an unnamed table; two arches collide byte-identically | **VERDICT: fixed spaces 0–3 stay; the custom axis is BLOCKED from the `0xC4` mint as carved.** The kill condition fired on a third possibility the row did not anticipate — neither "content" nor "reading", but a reading relative to a table absent from the address |
-| **W1** | the R2IL V4 tenant spec: ClassView carving of the 12 bytes for Op / Varnode-ref / macro-ref rows, written against `le-contract.md` §3 | field-isolation matrix test (I-LEGACY-API-FEATURE-GATED): write each field, assert all others unchanged. Any aliasing ⇒ re-carve |
-| **W2** | the `0xC4 BinaryLifting` mint (ruff PR3 arc, O5) — container concepts only, gated on W0's verdict for the space axis | mint request names concepts; a concept that encodes per-binary content is rejected by W0's rule |
+| **W1** | *(status 2026-08-25: **MAY PROCEED**, independently of W0's verdict — insofar as its carving work does not depend on the custom-space decision. Where it does touch that axis, it inherits W2's block.)* the R2IL V4 tenant spec: ClassView carving of the 12 bytes for Op / Varnode-ref / macro-ref rows, written against `le-contract.md` §3 | field-isolation matrix test (I-LEGACY-API-FEATURE-GATED): write each field, assert all others unchanged. Any aliasing ⇒ re-carve |
+| **W2** | ⛔ **BLOCKED-BY-OGAR-MINT-DECISION (W0 ran 2026-08-25).** The gate is no longer *"W0 decides how the space axis is carved"* — W0's verdict is that the **custom axis must not enter the mint in its current carving at all** (the lo-u16 is a rank inside a table the classid never names; two arches collide byte-identically). Fixed spaces 0–3 are unaffected and stay. **Do not resume W2 on the space axis** until OGAR rules on one of the three named-but-undecided options (arch in the address / raw SLEIGH identity / custom space outside the classid). Container concepts that do not touch the space axis are not blocked by this. | the original row's falsifier stands for the concept half; for the space half the block is the verdict, not a test to re-run. Entry: `E-W0-THE-SPACE-ORDINAL-IS-A-RANK-RELATIVE-TO-A-TABLE-THE-CLASSID-NEVER-NAMES-1` |
 | **W3** | palette wiring: macro-id byte → `{Learned,Explore}Palette[id]` → R2IL×BPE microcode, `ogar-loco` routing | B4-equivalent byte-exact round-trip through the palette; admission stays MUL's/the triangle's, NEVER the wiring's |
 | **W4** | `r2sleigh` seam: `r2sleigh-lift` emits INTO the tenant (R1 — no private graph then serialize). libsla STAYS — it is the oracle | parity: lift the same binary via today's path and via the tenant; byte-equal FlatFact streams. libsla removal is LAST (see below), never first |
 | **W5** | `lance-graph-java` facade: `PcodeOp`/`Instruction`/`Varnode` as lazy views over handles + masks | the mask-native gates (GraphHopTest allowlist, allocation gates) extended to the new views; `getPcode()` pays materialization ONLY when called — measured, not asserted |