diff --git a/.claude/board/LATEST_STATE.md b/.claude/board/LATEST_STATE.md index ffd0eb60c..b44ee386a 100644 --- a/.claude/board/LATEST_STATE.md +++ b/.claude/board/LATEST_STATE.md @@ -1,3 +1,29 @@ +## 2026-08-23 — #1006..#1014 MERGED — the belief-ABI arc: Step 1 audit, root-law probes, Step 2 ruling request, frontier Phases 1+2, the real-episode measurement + +Nine PRs (#1010/#1011 landing stacked via #1009's merge) closed the arc: + +- **What exists now:** Step-1 delegation audit (#1006, pure negative); + `probe_tarski_signed_witness` + `probe_four_plane_causal_medium` (#1007); + the stream-order epiphany + seam plan (#1008); three root-law probes + (#1009 — evidence generalization / falsification asymmetry / epistemic + fabric); the Step-2 ruling request + copula addendum + five measurement + probes (#1012); the frontier loop Phase 1 (styles = microcode; learner = + shipped revise + Stamp + CHOICE) and Phase 2 (R2IL typed receipts, the + clobber result) (#1013); the REAL FunctionBehavior episode measurement + (#1014 — 99.7% opcode over-admission vs 31.5% base rate; trigram + type-collapse 97 vs 264; Stamp mod-64 ceiling binds at 143 episodes). +- **Standing laws banked:** CONTENT NEVER TRAVELS IN CLASSID; HIERARCHY IS + THE ADDRESS SPACE NOT THE ONTOLOGY; GROUP MEMBERSHIP IS RELATION TOPOLOGY + NOT HHTL ANCESTRY; MEASURE THE DISTRIBUTION BEFORE BUYING THE + REPRESENTATION; sequential adjacency is not composition — the macro + carrier is the def-use chain. +- **PENDING (operator's, not the agent's):** the Step-2 ruling on the six + residue items (the stamp item now carries #1014's measured mod-64 + capacity number); the three-IF R2IL x BPE / OGAR-loco / V4 synthesis + remains hypothesis — nothing minted, reserved, or decided. +- **Arc rows:** `PR_ARC_INVENTORY.md` (this hygiene pass); NOTE the recorded + GAP MARKER — #976..#1005 (other sessions' arcs) still lack arc rows. + ## 2026-08-21 — D-ACR-7 IMPLEMENTED — `contract::band_reading` (the 59..63 reading contract) ### Current Contract Inventory — `VersionedGraph::hydrate_from`, and the CI gate that should have caught all of this diff --git a/.claude/board/PR_ARC_INVENTORY.md b/.claude/board/PR_ARC_INVENTORY.md index 30c4b2802..9d5be0231 100644 --- a/.claude/board/PR_ARC_INVENTORY.md +++ b/.claude/board/PR_ARC_INVENTORY.md @@ -1,3 +1,116 @@ +## 2026-08-23 — ⚠ GAP MARKER — #976..#1005 have no arc rows (other sessions' arcs) + +Roughly 20 PRs merged 2026-08-21..23 between #975 (the last row below) and +the #1006..#1014 arc recorded above this marker have NO arc-inventory rows. +Their EPIPHANIES / INTEGRATION_PLANS entries exist; the arc rows must come +from sessions that carry their context — this hygiene pass records only the +belief-ABI arc it can vouch for. Append-only: fill the gap by PREPENDING +dated rows above, never by editing here. + +## 2026-08-23 — lance-graph #1014 (MERGED, merge 4ec1e1b5, head 61df907d) — real FunctionBehavior episodes: opcode matching over-admits 99.7% + +- **Added:** `probe_r2il_real_episodes.rs` (5/5) — the frontier loop measured on + the REAL ruff-side R2IL pass-1 harvest (143 fns, 17,557 typed facts, Release + `r2il-harvest-pass1`; env-gated `R2IL_ORE_TSV`, exits CORPUS ABSENT, never + fabricates). E5 headline: 1/380 occurrences of the top opcode trigram are + dataflow-chained vs a 31.5% adjacency base rate — the macro carrier is the + def-use chain, never the linear opcode window. +- **Locked:** sequential adjacency ≠ composition on real code; real structure is + trigram TYPE-collapse (97 vs 264 shuffled), not top-1 count (that + pre-registration was refuted 380 vs 387 and is recorded in the gate); the + Stamp mod-64 ceiling BINDS at 143 episodes (~26% evidence CHOICE-dropped). +- **Deferred:** wider corpora; the Step-2 stamp residue ruling (now with a + measured capacity number). +- **Docs:** `E-REAL-CODE-INTERLEAVES-THE-OPCODE-MACRO-IS-NOT-A-DATAFLOW-PIPE-1`; + INTEGRATION_PLANS same-commit. +- **Confidence:** High for these 2 binaries at the pass-1 seven; not "all real + code." + +## 2026-08-23 — lance-graph #1013 (MERGED, merge c426547d, head ef91b30f) — Phase 2: R2IL typed receipts; happy-path RL would have learned the clobber + +- **Added:** `probe_r2il_frontier_phase2.rs` (7/7) — Phase-1 loop lifted onto + R2IL-shaped typed ops (probe-local mirror of `ruff_r2il`; never imported). R6: + a reckless macro (right value, wrong register, clobbers callee-saved r3) + reaches e=0.812 — above the trust bar — under a sloppy happy-path oracle and + is refused ONLY by the falsification intervention. +- **Locked:** BEFORE + TYPED EDIT = AFTER at machine-state level; fence sizes + MEASURED not guessed (Vn=8B/R2Op=28B/MachState=32B — the gate's first run + failed on guesses). +- **Deferred:** real episode streams (delivered by #1014). +- **Docs:** `E-HAPPY-PATH-RL-WOULD-HAVE-LEARNED-THE-CLOBBER-1`. +- **Confidence:** High for the mechanism; toy machine + probe-local oracles. + +## 2026-08-23 — lance-graph #1012 (MERGED, merge 794598aa) — Step 2 ruling request + copula addendum + five probes (Phase 1, membership, token-BPE, copula distribution, mask algebra) + +- **Added:** `belief-abi-step2-ruling-request-v1.md` (+ copula addendum) — six + residue items, ALL [RECOMMENDATION]-labelled with falsifiers, agent prepares / + operator rules; probes: `probe_style_microcode_frontier` (9/9 — the frontier + learner is ALREADY SHIPPED: revise + Stamp + CHOICE), + `probe_multi_group_membership` (11/11 — Membership 36B pinned), + `probe_token_bpe_geometry` (8/8 — CAN-FIT, NOT YET BUY), + `probe_copula_distribution` (5/5 — real KJV via `stance::stream`), + `probe_copula_group_mask` (9/9), `probe_mask_algebra_invariance` (7/7). +- **Locked:** CONTENT NEVER TRAVELS IN CLASSID (copula→classid retracted in + place); copula home = shipped `nars::facet_fold` (0 bytes, candidate E); + GROUP MEMBERSHIP IS RELATION TOPOLOGY NOT HHTL ANCESTRY; BEHAVIORAL + COMPRESSION CARRIER: UNDECIDED; the widened R2IL x BPE / OGAR-loco / V4 + synthesis recorded as a three-IF hypothesis, nothing decided. +- **Corrections recorded:** "KJV Rel-heavy" REFUTED (Inh 13 / Rel 2); + "tactics Impl" was a phantom (stance is the producer); two prior commits' + claimed board entries had silently no-opped — re-authored with post-write + assertions (all board writes assertion-verified since). +- **Docs:** `E-THE-FRONTIER-LEARNER-IS-ALREADY-SHIPPED-1`, + `E-MEMBERSHIP-IS-PARTICIPATION-NOT-ANCESTRY-1`, + `E-TOKEN-BPE-CAN-FIT-NOT-YET-BUY-1`, `E-CONTENT-NEVER-TRAVELS-IN-CLASSID-1`, + `E-HHTL-COMPILES-HIERARCHY-INTO-MASK-GEOMETRY-1`. +- **Confidence:** High for the measurements; the ruling itself is PENDING — + operator's, not the agent's. + +## 2026-08-23 — lance-graph #1009 (MERGED, merge 4cb36614; carried the stacked #1010 + #1011 content) — three root-law probes + +- **Added:** `probe_evidence_generalization` (7/7 — HIERARCHY IS THE ADDRESS + SPACE, NOT THE ONTOLOGY; zero-copy where the carrier is ABI-resident); + `probe_falsification_asymmetry` (7/7 — Auslöschung is a READING, never a + stored sum; falsifier PROPAGATION is O(1), discovery not claimed); + `probe_epistemic_fabric` (9/9 — seven epistemic states; + `LearnedSurvivedTests` is the only state licensing a learned transformation; + absence is evidence only under closure receipts). +- **Locked:** the three laws above, each with its measured boundary + (provenance required; closure warrant required). +- **Note:** #1010/#1011 were stacked onto this branch during the dirty-merge + resolution; their content landed via this merge. +- **Docs:** matching EPIPHANIES + INTEGRATION_PLANS entries per probe. +- **Confidence:** High. + +## 2026-08-23 — lance-graph #1008 (MERGED, merge d333bd84) — stream-order-vs-prefix-tree epiphany + seam plan + +- **Added:** the banked negative finding (time is not recoverable from the + prefix tree; the sorted stream carries it) + the Step-3 seam plan. +- **Locked (recut):** the invalid "A is not it, B is not it ⇒ A×B is it" + composition WITHDRAWN per review — "Time is time. Address is address." +- **Confidence:** High for the negative finding. + +## 2026-08-23 — lance-graph #1007 (MERGED, merge c5b44541) — Tarski signed witness + four-plane causal medium + +- **Added:** `probe_tarski_signed_witness` (11/11 — 24×i4 signed derivational + field: +support / 0 unresolved / −falsification; falsification never erases + the proposition) and `probe_four_plane_causal_medium` (7/7 — HHTL WHERE / + CE64 WHAT / G24N4 WHY / V4 DID / NARS f,c HOW STRONGLY stay distinguishable + on one memory ABI). +- **Locked (recut per review):** A9 semantic contract — same geometry, different + ClassView, ZERO shared vocabulary (magnitudes never through the `Locus` API); + rung proof de-circularized (`derive_depth_from_support`); `CausalRow` + labelled PROBE FIXTURE. +- **Confidence:** High for the geometry; V4 classid provisional (O5). + +## 2026-08-23 — lance-graph #1006 (MERGED, merge 9a6532bf) — Step 1: delegation-verification audit (pure negative) + +- **Added:** the Step-1 audit of the belief-ABI restoration charter. +- **Locked (recut per review):** the "trivial per-arena-position address" and + the premise-width conflation WITHDRAWN — the audit is a pure negative + deliverable; stale heading fixed in the second review round. +- **Confidence:** High as an audit; it decides nothing. + ## 2026-08-21 — lance-graph #975 (MERGED, merge commit 4a43698, head 5577728) — two measured corrections: the DisMech oracle population, and the academic carve fill; plus a retracted absence - **Added — the oracle-population correction (`5fac79d` + `5577728`),